Thursday, March 01, 2007


Ayaan Hirsi Ali, koan posted by MD
Back at the old version of this blog, I wrote a short piece that suggested that Theo Van Gogh's brutal murder presented a "special problem" for Western progressives. Specifically, I said it was a koan — either to be wrestled with, or completely ignored.

I should have added then (so I will now) that the exact same thing is the case for Western progressives (i.e., non-classical liberals) with Ayaan Hirsi Ali. In my own survey of the blogosphere, I am continually amazed at just how much Ali and Van Gogh are completely ignored by the progressives. But, again, I think I know why. Koans are difficult to deal with. The temptation at every juncture is to say, "to hell with this" and go on pretending the confusion isn't there. Or to convince oneself that there is no confusion. It is human nature to take the path of least resistance. The problem is that learning is never that path.

Jay Nordlinger echoes all of this, in his own way, here (scroll down a bit). His kosmic kwote:
Hirsi Ali, as you know, is the phenomenally brave woman from Holland, who was born in Somalia and now lives in the United States. And I don’t know whether anyone else in the world so discomforts liberals and leftists. I will indulge in psychological speculation:

She discomforts them because she highlights their own cowardice before the jihad. They would rather not focus on things that Hirsi Ali knows we should focus on. They would rather think about global warming — in which the villains are George W. Bush, the Republican party, and capitalism. You know: very easy. When you criticize Republicans and SUV-drivers, they don’t put a knife through your chest.

Labels:

  7:17 AM |   Email This!  Questions & Comments (0)

0 Comments:


Post a Comment







©2006 Polysemy. All rights reserved.
RSS   ATOM  


POLYSEMY Home

see also...

The Woodshed
staff podcast & blog

Elegant Thorn Review
poetry & photography

The Bookshelf
artist paideia




Have a comment?
matthew at
polysemy dot org




MD's Associations

Film Music Society
American Music Center
WFMT Chicago
Music Together
Sweat Pea's Studio
St. Luke Ministries
Chicago Public Library
Lakeshore Athletic Club
TuneCore



MD's Teachers

music
W.A. Mathieu
Amy Wurtz
Kyle Adams
Mark Davis
James Allen
James John
Dean Sorenson
Joe Hagedorn
Adam Larrabee
Grandmother Gertrude


poetry & prose
Yusef Komunyakaa
Carter Revard
Eddy Harris


the great ideas
The Basic Program
@ U of Chicago

Washington University
B.A., English Literature



Favored Reads

Camille Paglia
(another archive)
MLB.com
Encyclopedia of Chicago
The Corner
Phi Beta Cons
Arts & Letters Daily
Arion
International Music Score Library Project
Classical Homeschooling Magazine
Pitchfork Media
The New Criterion
Coughing in Ink
About Last Night
Integral World
Roger Ebert
James Lileks
Mothering
Hot Air
Tapped
Townhall
Buddhist Geeks